Last week I attended a symposium at MIT on the topic of quality in online learning. In addition to visiting this amazing local museum and an opportunity to hear the talents of MIT’s oldest vocal ensemble, I had a chance to participate in a whirlwind 48 hour idea and design fest devoted to quality in online learning. Jointly organized by our colleagues in the College Ready team and MIT’s Office of Educational Technology and Innovation, the meeting brought together about 80 individuals (grantees and non-grantees that included researchers and faculty, representatives from online learning solutions and tools, and representatives from grantee school districts and CMOs). The stated goal of the symposium was to “launch a national conversation on the quality of online learning in K-12 education.”
The meeting agenda, list of participants, and presentations have been posted online. In addition (if you’re interested) you can also view the twitter stream from the entire 2 days.The meeting was organized into a half day of presentations. Panels included a number of CRW grantees including (Arizona State University, Creative Commons) as well as representatives from industry and the broader online learning sector (Bror Saxberg from Kaplan and Judy Codding from the Pearson Foundation). The panels focused on three broad topics:
- Immersive Gaming / Focused Tutoring
- Quality Assessment: Assessing Course Quality
- Scaling Quality
The symposium also brought together a student panel consisting of four high school students, two teachers from Highline School District and Bellevue School District, as well as a team of researchers led by Dr. Phillip Bell from the University of Washington’s College of Education. The student/faculty panel discussed in detail their use of Educurious in the classroom. A core highlight from this session was learning first-hand how the resource enables students to tap into a network of accomplished and seasoned professionals (as thought partners and information resources) over the course of completing particular assignments and research problems. It was also really interesting to hear how teachers felt “relieved” by having a resource like Educurious to depend on because it reduced the pressure that they felt “relieved for not having to know everything” and more importantly, were now empowered to connect students to other external resources that could provide students with the expertise and information that they needed. The students’ excitement and engagement in their learning and the process was also palpable and very cool.
In a talk titled the “Opportunity and Challenge of Pervasive Quality”, Jim Shelton pushed us all to create more durable and lasting learning innovations that benefit our students, faster. Mr. Shelton first spoke about two recurring challenges regarding innovation in education:
- A tendency to think learning will happen because of innovations in hardware (i.e., magical device + student = improved student learning and mastery)
- A tendency to focus on the perfect rather than the good – we tend to focus on “what would be great”) and swirl in circles rather than focusing on “what can be great”
While he acknowledge the existence of weighty academic debates regarding the attributes and characteristics of a high-quality online learning experience, Mr. Shelton (ever the pragmatist) asked us to focus on the most important factor. Find, test, build, and scale learning experiences and environments that first and foremost deliver better student learning outcomes and mastery. Online learning should be about learning – not bells and whistles.
Learning. Plain and simple.
P.S. I expect in a couple of months that we will actually see the outcomes and learning from the workshop delivered back to the public for further discussion.
P.S.S. A special shout out to colleagues in our College Ready team for organizing such a great symposium.